Cases
Real matters with concrete numbers. No generalities — only facts.
Project
Situation
Result
Tax disputes · Construction
Tax audit ruled unlawful: CIT and VAT assessments of KZT 49 million cancelled
The tax authority disallowed CIT and VAT deductions of KZT 36 million because of a criminal case against a counterparty and assessed KZT 49 million including late-payment interest. The administrative court ruled the audit unlawful and cancelled all assessments. The appeal court upheld the decision, and the cassation court upheld both the decision and the appeal ruling.
49 M ₸
in assessments overturned
VAT / Taxpayer account
Error in VAT taxpayer account — recovered 60.7 million tenge of unlawfully withheld balance
The tax authority erroneously adjusted the VAT taxpayer account seven times, generating fictitious debt.
60.7 M ₸
in unlawfully withheld balance
VAT / Reorganisation
Unlawful VAT write-off during reorganisation — court reversed 48 million tenge of assessments and interest
After absorbing another legal entity, the tax authority wrote off the transferred positive VAT balance two years later and assessed 37 million tenge plus interest. The court declared the actions unlawful.
48.5 M ₸
in assessments and interest overturned
Customs disputes
Customs authority's decision on non-execution of notice reversed by court
The customs authority deemed the notice not executed even though the client had submitted a written response with the full set of documents within the prescribed period. The court reversed the decision.
3.6 M ₸
in unlawful assessments overturned
Tax audits
Filed objections to the preliminary decision on an unscheduled audit — the tax authority withdrew the audit after our arguments
The tax authority (ДГД) initiated an unscheduled audit requiring adjustment of the returns and additional payment of VAT, CIT and interest totalling over 48 million tenge. After our objections were submitted, the audit was cancelled.
48 M ₸
in potential assessments prevented
IIT / Inheritance
Reversal of IIT on sale of inherited apartments — the tax authority incorrectly determined the holding period
The tax authority assessed IIT of 4.1 million tenge on the sale of apartments previously held in joint marital ownership. After the wife's death, the heir sold the apartments — the tax authority considered the holding period to be less than a year.
4.1 M ₸
in unlawfully assessed IIT
Tax disputes / Cassation
Supreme Court reversed CIT and VAT assessments — tax audit conducted before the court ruling entered into force
The tax authority conducted an audit during the period when the notice execution deadline was suspended by court proceedings. The Supreme Court declared the audit unlawful and reversed assessments of 34 million tenge.
34 M ₸
in CIT, VAT and interest assessments overturned
Tax disputes
CIT and VAT assessments of 296 million tenge overturned — tax authority breached audit deadlines
Following an unscheduled audit the client was assessed CIT and VAT of 296 million tenge. The court reversed the notice due to breach of audit deadlines and unjustified exclusion of deductions.
296 M ₸
in CIT and VAT assessments overturned
Tax disputes
Assessments of 1 billion tenge overturned — audit appointed without an order of the authorised body
At the prosecutor's request the tax authority conducted a comprehensive audit and assessed over 1 billion tenge. The court reversed all the results: the Committee had not issued the mandatory order appointing the audit.
1 bn ₸
in tax assessments overturned
Transfer pricing
Unscheduled transfer pricing audit cancelled — КГД order issued without specific facts of breaches
The State Revenue Committee appointed an unscheduled transfer pricing audit on the request of a lower body — without specifying any concrete facts of breaches. The court reversed both the order and the audit instruction.
Audit cancelled
before any assessments
Tax disputes
CIT assessments of 1.1 billion tenge overturned — audit appointed without specific grounds
Following an unscheduled comprehensive audit the client was assessed CIT and interest of 1.1 billion tenge. The court reversed the notice: the КГД order was issued on the request of a lower body without specific facts of breaches, and the audit extension was formalised as a letter rather than a decision.
1.1 bn ₸
in CIT and interest assessments overturned
Tax disputes
CIT and VAT assessments of 43 million tenge overturned — audit conducted for a period outside the instruction
The tax authority conducted an audit for a tax period not specified in the instruction and exceeded the grounds of the audit by including a counterparty not mentioned in the order. The appeal court reversed all assessments.
43 M ₸
in CIT, VAT and interest assessments overturned
Recognise your situation?
Send us the notice or the audit report. We will tell you whether there are grounds to have it cancelled.
